ONE-SYS / Blog

The Poverty of Business

Fabrizio Mantelli5 min read
The Poverty of Business

“Business as usual”, “Business first”, “nothing personal, it’s just business”, “Businessman”: all expressions that may suggest a form of powerlessness, perhaps not fully acknowledged by those who use them. Yet, particularly in the Western world, the word “business” is associated with power.

“He did a lot of business, poor man!” I have heard that said at more than one funeral!

So what are we to make of this? Frankly, my understanding of the word business is beginning to waver.

Is there perhaps a missing building block, or more than one, that could eliminate or at least ease that sense of powerlessness? A building block that would complete the meaning we unconsciously give to business?

The world of business—yes, the world of “deals” and “commerce” in the broadest sense, the one most of us see as a normal part of the world—began with humankind.

Business was born with reason, the defining faculty of a thinking being.
Cultural development, particularly scientific progress, and technological advancement have led to the creation and growth of the world economy, which has become the fulcrum on which all the global levers of business exert their forces.

It goes without saying that the course of the entire planet’s economy pulls everyone, willingly or not, in a common direction.
Does this mean that humanity as a whole pursues wealth and capital at any cost?

Even more central than revenues are costs, deeply hidden, almost invisible. From time to time, these costs cause harm that is almost never attributed to them. Society views and judges this harm with astonishment, often describing it as chance events or misfortunes.

These are uncomfortable costs, to which some forms of capitalism seem to develop a kind of selective blindness. A blindness that goes beyond ignoring their existence and, through sophisticated mechanisms of communication and consensus-building, can even remove them from collective awareness, preventing those costs from becoming visible as the prices society is called upon to pay.

The blindness induced by the illusion of “well-being” to be achieved quickly is the marketing strategy used by those in power to influence the masses.

The costs are distributed among the individual inhabitants of the planet, becoming almost “negligible” for the “few” who hold enough power to offset them more than adequately, without ever managing to erase them entirely.

In many cases, the oligarchy of power and wealth ends up generating an internal ethic built on values derived from business objectives.

These values, which contradict those of the majority, are accepted and, above all, shared among the members of these fraternities of power as a way of shedding personal responsibility.
All of this helps reduce the individual sense of guilt through a complacent collective conscience, and the job is done.

And so, justifications flourish within these oligarchies of moral poverty: “we have no other choice”, “we will see the benefits over time”, “we can no longer turn back”.

Over the past 25 years, scandals linked to these dynamics have involved hidden costs passed on to society; business objectives placed above safety; harm to health driven by economic incentives; the internal normalisation of misconduct and the diffusion of responsibility; and misleading representations of reality.

These are real, widely discussed cases that illustrate the nature of the costs passed on to society that I am referring to.

Costs that should prompt us to reflect on the need for an approach that considers not only the economic and functional objectives of the systems we create, but also their consequences for people, society and the environment.
It is precisely from this perspective that Systems Engineering, through its multidisciplinary approach and a broader ethical awareness, can make a fundamental contribution to safeguarding humanity.

We systems engineers should ask not only “Are we building the system correctly?” but also “Is it right to build this system, considering all the consequences it may generate?”

Consequences = Hidden costs.

The proper application of Systems Engineering must bring the costs to humanity to light.

The consequences, the costs, the prices to be paid may be environmental, social, economic, political or health-related.

Teams of systems engineers have both the duty and the right to know exactly what system they are working on, even if their system of interest is only one part of it. It will be their responsibility to exercise their personal freedom of choice on the basis of their own ethical principles.

It goes without saying that, to give this aspect its proper weight, organisations must allow engineering teams to speak freely and, where necessary, to dissent without individuals facing repercussions. Otherwise, we would once again be talking about costs and prices to be paid.

Engineering teams will not always be able to know every detail of a system, perhaps for reasons of confidentiality, but they must know its purposes.

Increasingly advanced and complex systems must be conceived and developed on these premises. Scientific and cultural progress will allow us to design ever more complex systems. That same scientific and cultural progress will enable us to make them safer, more useful and less harmful to other systems: in other words, it will give us the ability to reveal hidden costs and then reduce them.

It is not only the ability to design better systems that we lack; sometimes we lack the willingness to ask the right questions before designing them.

The true poverty of business lies not in a lack of resources, but in the inability to recognise the human price of its decisions.

Contact us

Contact us

We only use necessary technical cookies. Analytics and marketing are not active. You can manage or withdraw preferences at any time.